Do Tele-Town Halls Shield Lawmakers from Rowdy Crowds? (Politico)

View full article at

The telephone town hall, a forum that members of Congress insist offers them an opportunity to reach out to more constituents than through traditional town halls, is coming under increasing scrutiny from critics who insist that the events are largely rigged and designed to shield skittish lawmakers from facing hostile questioning.

While the tele-town hall isn’t exactly a new communications tool, it’s hard not to notice the sudden proliferation of these events at a time when members have struggled to control raucous crowds and deal with the presence of unfriendly, camera-wielding attendees who are eager to post unflattering videos on the Internet.

Lawmakers insist the tele-town halls enable them to reach out to far more constituents at any one time than an in-person event would. Conservative activists, however, contend that elected officials don’t want to face the music and prefer a more controlled environment where they can cherry-pick questions and dodge the opposition.

In North Carolina, FreedomWorks organizer Joyce Krawiec said that members of her group who called in to some House members’ conference calls reported back that they were unable to ask a question.

In North Dakota, conservative local radio host and blogger Rob Port described a similar experience when he phoned in to Democratic Rep. Earl Pomeroy’s conference call, despite calling in early to get in line to ask a question. The operator, he said, asked whether he supported or opposed President Barack Obama’s health care plan. When Port said he was undecided — an attempt to ensure that he got to ask a question — he was put on hold for what seemed to him to be an interminable period.

After the first round of questions included a local Service Employees International Union representative, followed by another pro-Obama group’s representative, Port eventually hung up.

It’s an experience that’s been reported across the country over the past two months. Waco, Texas-area tea party organizer Toby Marie Walker and members of her group signed up for an Aug. 20 teleconference with Democratic Rep. Chet Edwards, but some say they never received a call at the appointed time. A few others in the group got on the call but weren’t chosen to ask a question.

“They know me because I call them every day,” Walker said. “He knows who we are, so I guess we didn’t expect to ask any questions.”

Asked for comment about the complaints, a spokesman for Edwards offered this statement.

“Our telephone town hall meeting on health care dialed nearly 200,000 homes in all 12 District 17 counties, and nearly 20,000 constituents participated. Our public town halls in Bryan, Waco and Cleburne were well attended by over 3,000 people. The congressman also participated in health care forums with constituents via webcast and radio call-in programs,” said Josh Taylor. “While some would play politics with the issue of health care, Congressman Edwards believes the issue is too important to our families and country to be influenced by partisan politics.”

Congressional offices and technology experts contacted by POLITICO admit that telephone conference calls are often orchestrated to some degree, but they say they aren’t screening for softballs. Rather, the explanation is that attempts are made to shield lawmakers from unruly behavior.

By pre-screening questions through congressional staffers and using robocalls to reach a random sampling of voters, they note, notorious troublemakers can be kept off the line and a fair balance of opinions heard.

Several congressional offices say that they select questions based on topic, rather than in the order they’re received, to allow lawmakers to address a wide variety of topics and eliminate repeat questions.

When POLITICO listened to 10 recent telephone town halls across the country, the questions posed to lawmakers from both parties tended to be sympathetic or, in some cases, almost fawning.

9,000 Tune in to Murtha Teleconference (Our Town)

View full article at

The public debate over health care reform burnt up the phone lines in five counties when U.S. Rep. John Murtha held an hour-long teleconference with constituents on Thursday evening.

Representatives for the Democratic congressman said that of the 40,000 homes that were called in Cambria, Fayette, Indiana, Somerset, and Westmoreland counties, more than 9,000 stayed on the line for an average of 16 minutes.

“My goal is that as diversified as this country is that you’re heard,” Murtha said in the opening minutes of the event.

He told those listening that the reform process was in the early stages and legislation would take time to hammer out.

“There are so many plans floating around I can’t tell you which one will pass, if any of them,” he said of the five currently in the House and Senate.

That wasn’t to say he didn’t believe reform was necessary. “We have to find a way to get these costs down. We have to get coverage for people with pre-existing conditions.”

Those ideas — along with reducing the cost of administration and prescription drugs — were the core of what Democratic proponents are calling a “uniquely American” reform platform.

For Murtha, insurance-covered abortions and changing Medicare and/or TRICARE (the military benefit plan) are all off the table.

“You know my feeling on abortion,” he told Harold from Ebensburg after the question. “I won’t vote for a bill that has it.”

Murtha fielded 27 questions from callers that were largely complimentary. Topics ranged from health care to immigration reform to the war in Afghanistan.

More than 150 people left messages on the iConstituent system that will be replied to in the coming days, spokesman Matt Mazonkey said.

Several callers like Donna in Johnstown asked the congressman to curb illegal immigration, claiming the cost of education and health care for those in the country illegally was exorbitant.

Murtha said that illegal immigration would slow when an electronic employee eligibility verification system was completely online in the near future.

“They’re here because of jobs. If they can’t get them, there’s no incentive to stay,” he said.

Others, like Lynn in Ebensburg just want those in government to stop spending, whether it be for stimulus packages or on health care reform. “There’s no more money,” she said. “We have to work within a budget.”

Murtha said that the best way to bring the nation out of the financial downturn would be to create jobs, which he hoped some of the stimulus spending would do.

(Dan DiPaolo can be contacted at Comment on the story at

Welcome to the New!

Welcome to the new! We are very proud of our newly redesigned corporate website. The site will serve as a valuable tool for both our current and prospective clients. This fresh new design comes just weeks after the launch of the Constituent Gateway version 3.0! These two new designs demonstrate the continued innovation and cutting edge design work that have helped position iConstituent as the leading provider of constituent communication services for elected officials.

Our new site includes the following tools:

  • Blog: stay on top of the latest tricks and trends, new Constituent Gateway product releases, and other exciting news with our new blog!
  • Gateway Login: easy access to your account with a simple login from the home page.
  • Case Studies: our prospective clients will benefit from seeing one of our many success stories.
  • E-Newsletter Archive: access all of our important announcements with ease from our e-newsletter archive.

We thank you for your continued support and welcome any comments or feedback on the new site!

Announcing the Release of Virtual Town Hall!

The Constituent Gateway Virtual Town Hall gives you a new way to connect with your constituents online!  With this new product, you will be able to conduct real-time, online town hall meetings with your constituents. Features include:

  • Meet and discuss the issues with hundreds of your constituents in real time, right from your office!
  • Invite your constituents via email using the Constituent Gateway or post an invitation on your website
  • Broadcast streaming audio and video
  • Host moderated question and answer sessions
  • Conduct real-time polling
  • Share PowerPoint presentations, graphics, charts, and more!
  • Review detailed reporting
  • Post a complete recording of the completed Virtual Town Hall on your website

No special software is required – just an internet connection and a web browser. For more information, including a demo, please contact